The LER adds two ratios: the crop yield under the system divided by that of a reference plot, and the system's energy divided by that of a conventional plant on the same area. A value above 1 indicates that producing the same output separately would require more land. It is not enough by itself: you must check that the crop remains the primary use.
Where it comes from
Mead and Willey (1980) defined the LER for intercropping: it is the area of sole crops needed to obtain the same yields achieved on one hectare of the intercropped system. Dupraz et al. (2011) applied it to the combination of crop and photovoltaic energy, and Weselek et al. (2019) include it as a method to assess combined land productivity.
The formula
LER = (Y_system / Y_ref) + (E_system / E_ref).
Y_system is the crop yield under the agrivoltaic system and Y_ref that of a reference plot without modules, with the same soil, variety and management. E_system is the annual energy of the agrivoltaic system per hectare and E_ref that of a conventional ground-mounted photovoltaic plant, with the same technology, on the same hectare.
An illustrative numerical example
The numbers below are made up only to show the calculation; they are not data from any project.
Suppose the crop under the system yields 85% of the reference plot (0.85) and the system produces 50% of the energy of a conventional plant on the same hectare (0.50). Then LER = 0.85 + 0.50 = 1.35. Producing the same output separately would require 1.35 ha: one hectare of crop and part of another hectare of solar plant.
How to interpret it and common mistakes
A LER above 1 indicates more efficient use of land, but it does not say whether the crop remains the primary use. A crop yielding 0.20 and a system producing 0.95 of the energy give LER = 1.15, even though farming almost disappears. That is why Weselek et al. (2019) call for a minimum agricultural yield, and the DIN SPEC 91434 standard (2021) requires the yield to reach at least 66% of the reference.
Other frequent mistakes: comparing against a plot that does not have the same soil or management, measuring a single season, estimating reference energy with a different technology or density, and assuming the LER measures income when it only measures physical output.
What data are needed
Crop yield measured in the system and in the reference plot over several seasons; for the reference yield, the DIN SPEC 91434 standard allows averages of recent years or statistics for the area. Energy measured on the system's meter, and an estimate of the energy of a conventional ground-mounted plant with the same technology. And a record of crop management, so that the two plots are comparable.
The Analyze my site simulation is a preliminary estimate and does not calculate the LER of a real project; the LER can only be confirmed with measured data.
This article is informative. It is not agronomic or tax advice or a quote, and results depend on each site.
References
- Mead R., Willey R.W. (1980). The concept of a 'land equivalent ratio' and advantages in yields from intercropping. Experimental Agriculture, 16(3): 217-228. doi:10.1017/S0014479700010978
- Dupraz C., Marrou H., Talbot G., Dufour L., Nogier A., Ferard Y. (2011). Combining solar photovoltaic panels and food crops for optimising land use: Towards new agrivoltaic schemes. Renewable Energy, 36(10): 2725-2732. doi:10.1016/j.renene.2011.03.005
- Weselek A., Ehmann A., Zikeli S., Lewandowski I., Schindele S., Högy P. (2019). Agrophotovoltaic systems: applications, challenges, and opportunities. A review. Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 39: 35. doi:10.1007/s13593-019-0581-3
- DIN e.V. (2021). DIN SPEC 91434:2021-05. Agri-photovoltaic systems: requirements for primary agricultural use. Beuth Verlag. din.de